Warm pine-paneled cabin living room with an original stone fireplace, ivory sofa and windows overlooking November woods in Michiana Shores.

Why Michiana Shores Is Still a Town of Old Cabins

November 19, 2026

In the late 1930s, a log cabin in Michiana Shores was advertised at $1,400, plus $395 for the land. Most of the first cabins went up along Hiawatha Trail. Locals came to call the street "school teacher row" because so many Chicago teachers bought cabins there and spent their summers in the woods.

Many of those cabins are still standing, and the town around them has grown slowly. The Michiana Shores Comprehensive Plan, adopted by the Town Council on May 9, 2023, counts 274 houses in 1982 and 346 in 2022. That's fewer than two new houses a year. Anyone shopping in Michiana Shores is mostly choosing among houses that already exist, and many of those houses date to the cabin era.

A Cabin Town Built Around Keeping the Trees

The first subdivision was platted in 1927. The developers planned a resort. The lots closest to the lake were set aside for a club, a hotel or other businesses, and one subdivision was meant to become a golf course. None of that was built, and by 1930 houses already stood where the businesses were supposed to go. In 1932 the land went back to the Long Beach Company, whose president was Orphie W. Gotto.

Gotto and his partner, Clarence Mathias, then decided to make Michiana Shores a log-cabin town. The town plan says many of the cabins were small and not always well built. The better ones came from a German-Swiss builder named Bill Jash, who, the story goes, didn't like working from blueprints. More than 100 log cabins went up, and many are still standing, though some have since been enlarged or re-sided. The company's slogan was "Your cabin in the woods," and the plan says it built with care to keep the grounds as wooded as possible.

You can see the cabin tradition outside the residential streets too. According to Dunes Arts' history page, its theater building dates to 1941, and visiting artists and interns stay in cabins on the campus. The Dunes Arts Foundation was established in 1951.

The setting still matches the slogan. The town is mostly wooded, sits on fine sandy soil and ranges from about 590 to 650 feet in elevation. The plan says the same kind of terrain continues into Long Beach and Duneland Beach and across the state line into Michiana, Michigan, and Grand Beach. The woods and dunes look much the same across all of these towns. What sets Michiana Shores apart is its housing history.

More Than 1,200 Lots and Far Fewer Houses

The town covers about 212 acres, platted into more than 1,200 single-family lots, and most of those lots are 40 feet wide. Many lots have never had a house of their own, and new houses have been added slowly.

Subdivision Platted lots Houses, 1982 Houses, 2007
2 396 125 134
4 59 19 19
6 361 70 82
8 402 60 90
Total 1,218 274 325

The plan counts 346 houses by 2022. That works out to roughly 70 new houses in the 40 years since 1982. An earlier count from town records shows the same pace, about two new houses a year over a quarter century. The plan credits that growth to people rediscovering how close the town is to a Lake Michigan beach. Interest in the town has grown faster than the number of houses.

Building hasn't been spread evenly, either. North of White Ditch, in Subdivisions 2 and 4 near the lake, more than 70% of the land is developed, and Subdivision 2 added only nine houses between 1982 and 2007. South of the ditch, in Subdivisions 6 and 8, development is closer to 40%. Most new building has happened there, and the plan expects most future building there as well. It also notes that this southern area has severe drainage problems and the soil least suited to septic systems. The streets nearest the beach have changed the least since the cabin era.

Utilities are also a reminder of the town's age. Almost the entire town relies on individual septic systems, and drinking water comes from the Michigan City Water Department. In the plan, a public sewer system, probably shared with neighboring communities, is only a possible future option, and it calls that option "certainly the most complicated and expensive."

What Slow Growth Has Meant for Prices

The plan also tracks how values have changed. Until about the late 1980s, someone looking for a year-round home could find similarly priced houses in Michigan City and Michiana Shores. After that, the plan says, lots and houses near Lake Michigan, including Michiana Shores, gained value much faster than nearby inland areas. Growing demand for the lakeshore and a town that adds about two houses a year help explain that price gap.

Slow building also explains why the cabins have lasted. A town that added hundreds of houses would have mostly newer homes by now. Michiana Shores had 274 houses in 1982 and more than 100 log cabins dating back to the 1930s, so the older homes have always been a large share of what's for sale. Some of those cabins have been enlarged or re-sided over the years. That leaves a wide range of condition and character behind similar log exteriors. Some are close to the original Bill Jash build. Others have had decades of additions.

When you're comparing Michiana Shores with Long Beach or Duneland Beach, it helps to know how a house's history shows up in its price. For a cabin north of White Ditch, ask whether it's an original log build, how much it has been added on to and how the logs have held up, because those are the details buyers compare across the few houses that come up for sale nearby. South of the ditch, there's more open land and more recent houses to choose from, and the plan describes the ground there as harder to build on.

For more on the town around those cabins, see our Michiana Shores neighborhood page and our look at the volunteer Boosters who run so much of town life. If you're comparing towns, our Long Beach page covers the town next door, and inspectors and tradespeople who know older lakeshore homes are on our preferred vendors list.

If you're looking at a Michiana Shores cabin or thinking about selling one, I'm happy to walk through its history with you, from the original logs to every addition, and price it against the few comparable houses that sell nearby. Jordan Gallas has worked these beach towns since 2012. Let's Connect.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat.